Cybersecurity

It sounds like the boss: how voice scams and fake hires target Cayman businesses

Anyone can sound convincing on the phone, and anyone can look right on a video call. The defence is a habit of checking through a channel you already trust.

By the CNS team · · 6 min read

Illustration of a sound wave with a warning icon, joined by a dashed line to a person icon with a checkmark

Key takeaways

  • A short recording of your voice from a video or podcast can be enough to copy it.
  • Caller ID can be faked. Check payment changes, account resets and sign-in codes through a number you already have.
  • If the caller says the boss already approved it, check anyway.
  • Hiring is a security process too. Verify who you are hiring before you hand over equipment or switch on access.

Would your team question a payment request if the caller sounded exactly like you?

Your staff hear your voice every day. If you are travelling and a call comes in about an invoice, it sounds normal. But if you have ever recorded a video for your website or spoken on a podcast, someone could use that audio to copy your voice, then ring your bookkeeper and ask for a supplier’s bank details to be changed.

The same trick works in reverse. A confident person on a video call may not be who their CV says they are. This guide covers both, because the fix is the same: check who you are dealing with before money moves or access is granted.

How scammers copy a voice

Voice-cloning software can produce new speech in a voice it has been trained on, and a short clip is often enough. The FBI has warned that criminals use AI-generated audio to impersonate trusted people and obtain payments, and has also reported fake video calls involving supposed company executives.

An odd pause or strange wording might make you suspicious. A good copy will not, so your process needs to work even when the call sounds right.

Caller ID is no help on its own. Numbers can be spoofed, and a caller may say, “My usual phone isn’t working, ring me on this number.” Contact the person using details you already trust. Otherwise you may end up asking the scammer to confirm their own instructions.

Check every payment or bank-detail request

If a supplier asks you to use a different account, your employee can say: “I’ll call our usual contact to confirm that before I change anything.” The same applies to any unexpected request to send money, even when the caller knows the supplier’s name and the invoice amount.

  1. End the call and find a trusted number. Use your staff directory or supplier records, never the number in the message or invoice you are checking.
  2. Confirm with the real person. Ask whether they made the request, then check the amount, recipient and account details.
  3. Record what was confirmed. Keep the confirmation with the payment record so whoever approves it can see how the details were checked.

A follow-up email does not replace these checks. It could come from a lookalike address or a hacked supplier mailbox, and if you reply to ask about the bank details, the scammer may be the one answering. Our invoice fraud guide covers the email side in more detail.

If you cannot confirm the details, do not send the payment yet. Your staff also need someone to go to when a caller insists on an immediate payment or asks them to keep it quiet.

“The boss has already approved it”

If you are the person who approves payments, staff may treat your sign-off as enough. A scammer posing as you can claim you have already spoken to the supplier. Your employee should still call the supplier, even if the caller says you have done it.

Where payments need two approvals, put the callback confirmation in the record the second approver sees. Otherwise both people can approve a request without either checking who made it. If you have enough people, let one person update bank details and another approve the payment. Your bank can tell you what separate approvals you can set up on a business account.

If you are the only person making payments, you can still ring the supplier before using new details. And if a bill falls due while you are away, your team needs to know who else can approve it and what that person may authorise.

Account resets and “IT support” calls

If your phone approves your sign-ins and you lose it, you would need your IT provider to help you back in, and they would need a way to confirm it was really you. Someone impersonating you could call with the same story.

A good question to ask your provider: “If I lost my phone and called for help, how would you check it was me?” The answer should not rest only on your voice or the number on their screen.

Staff can protect themselves too. If someone claiming to be from IT rings, they can say, “I’ll check with the support desk first,” and then use the support number they already have. Sign-in codes and password-reset codes stay private, and a login prompt nobody started gets declined, even if the caller says it is part of fixing a problem.

Fake job applicants

Impersonation also arrives through the hiring process. Some fraudulent applicants are skilled workers who do real work under a false or concealed identity while you pay them and give them access to your systems. The UK government and Microsoft have both described schemes in which remote IT workers gain jobs and contracts using false identities. In some cases they have stolen source code or confidential data and demanded payment.

Any business that hires remote workers or freelancers can be targeted, including a small Cayman firm bringing in a web developer for a project. Some practical checks:

  • Contact references independently. If a candidate gives you a former manager’s email address, find the employer’s official contact details yourself. Confirm the referee works there and check the employment dates.
  • Ask your screening provider how it works. If a report only says “passed”, ask how they confirmed the person you are speaking to is the owner of the identity they checked. Handle candidate documents through your approved process, not by forwarding copies between inboxes.
  • Do not rely on a video interview alone. The FBI has documented facilitators attending virtual interviews on behalf of the person who will do the work. Ask the candidate to explain a decision they made on a past project, what went wrong, or how they would approach a problem in your business, and have someone with the right knowledge judge the answers.
  • Use a work sample. Give a short exercise on sample data in a test environment, not on live systems, customer records or admin accounts.
  • Agree with recruiters what “vetted” means. Find out who checks identity, who approves a replacement and whether subcontractors need the same checks. A replacement gets their own account, never the original contractor’s login.

In a small place like Cayman, the simplest control is to hand equipment over in person. That gives you the chance to check that the person in front of you matches the identity you verified, and to set up their account with them there. If a laptop does have to go to someone remote, confirm the delivery address through your hiring process and check that the required checks are finished first. Microsoft describes “laptop farms”, where company laptops are sent to a third party who keeps them online for a worker elsewhere. If an address changes, the hiring manager should approve it, and the record should show who did.

Once checks are complete, give the new person access to what the job needs and nothing else. A website contractor does not need the payroll folder. MFA protects an account from outsiders but does not prove who the user is, so it does not replace identity checks. IT should set up and manage company devices, keep a list of the remote-support tools your business uses, and review unusual sign-ins and large downloads in the first weeks.

If an identity concern is unresolved before the person starts, pause equipment and access while it is reviewed. If someone is already working for you, involve your IT provider and whoever handles HR straight away. Do not wipe the laptop or delete the account as a first move, because you may destroy the evidence you need. Bring in your legal advisers if you suspect fraud or data theft.

Make it easy to say “let me check”

It is awkward to tell your boss you need to verify what they have just asked. So tell your team in advance: “If someone calls and sounds like me, I still want you to check new payment details before you use them. I am happy to wait.”

  • Thank anyone who calls back to confirm a genuine request.
  • Run a practice call with whoever handles invoices or account resets. Let them show you where they would find the right number and what they would do if the caller said there was no time.
  • Give anyone covering for the bookkeeper the same contact list and instructions.
  • When someone reports an attempted scam, tell the rest of the team, even if nothing was lost.

If someone has already acted on a scam call

  • Money sent: call your bank or payment provider immediately, say the payment was fraudulent and ask whether it can be stopped or recalled. Do not wait until you have finished investigating.
  • Bank login or card details shared: tell your bank exactly what was given out and follow its advice.
  • Sign-in approved or codes shared: tell your IT provider which account was involved and roughly when, so they can secure it.
  • Keep the evidence: payment instructions, messages, call times, any voicemail, plus notes of what was said while memories are fresh.
  • Report it to the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service, and warn the person or supplier who was impersonated.
  • Personal data involved? Under the Cayman Data Protection Act, breaches must be reported to the Ombudsman, and to the people affected, within five days. Our Data Protection Act checklist explains what to do.

Common questions

Can someone copy my voice without hacking my phone?

Yes. A recording from a video or podcast you have posted can give them the audio they need.

Should I remove every video that includes my voice?

Deleting a video will not remove copies someone has already saved. You can reduce what you share publicly, but your staff still need to verify payment changes and account requests.

What if the supplier really has changed their phone number?

Call the supplier’s main office using details from your existing records, or contact someone else you already know there. Ask for someone authorised to confirm the new number and the payment details, and do not change the bank details until you have confirmed both.

Is a video interview enough to confirm an applicant’s identity?

No. Someone can attend on another person’s behalf, and stolen identity documents belong to real people. Combine the interview with identity checks and references you verify independently.

Should we hand over equipment before hiring checks are finished?

No. Wait until the checks are complete. Where you can, hand the equipment over in person and check the person against the identity you verified. If it has to be sent, the hiring manager should confirm the approved delivery address first.

How CNS can help

We work with Cayman businesses on the checks that make these scams fail: payment and approval processes, MFA, account-recovery procedures, device management and staff awareness. If you want to find out where your process is exposed, we can walk through a request with you, from the first call to the final approval. Book a free network assessment or call (345) 945-2755.

Sources

Questions about your own setup?

Talk to a Cayman IT expert. No obligation, no jargon.

Get in touch (345) 945-2755